AI Overviews are taking clicks: what small businesses should do now

A physiotherapy clinic in Salt Lake (I’ll use it as an example; the pattern is real, the clinic is made up) wrote a long article in 2024 called “Exercises for lower back pain at home”. By early 2025 it was the clinic’s most visited page, around 1,800 visits a month from Google. Today the same page still ranks on page one, still gets shown to roughly the same number of people, and gets about a third of the clicks.

Nothing is wrong with the page. Google simply answers the question itself now. Search for back pain exercises and an AI Overview at the top lists five stretches with short instructions. Most people read that and leave.

If you run a small business and your Search Console shows impressions holding steady while clicks drop, this is very likely why.

What the numbers say

Two studies are worth knowing, because they measured the same thing in different ways.

Pew Research Center tracked the real browsing of 900 American adults in March 2025. When an AI summary appeared, people clicked a normal search result on 8% of visits. Without a summary, they clicked on 15%. They also ended their browsing session more often after seeing a summary (26% against 16%).

Ahrefs compared 300,000 keywords and found that the top-ranking page got about 34.5% fewer clicks when an AI Overview was shown above it.

Both studies are from the US, and Google disputes the conclusions. But India isn’t far behind. Google rolled out AI Mode for Indian users in English in 2025 and added Hindi in September 2025, and AI Overviews already appear on a large share of searches here.

Not every search is affected the same way

This is the part most “SEO is dead” posts skip. AI Overviews show up mostly on long, informational questions. Pew found them on only 8% of one- or two-word searches, but on 53% of searches with ten words or more.

Think about what your customers actually type:

Type of searchExampleAI Overview likely?Worth chasing?
How-to / general question“exercises for lower back pain”Very likelyFor trust, not for traffic
Comparison“physiotherapy vs chiropractor”OftenYes, if you add your own view and prices
Service + place“physiotherapist in Salt Lake”Rarely; the map pack showsYes, this is where customers are
Brand“XYZ Physio Clinic timings”RarelyYes, keep your Google profile right
Ready to buy“home visit physiotherapy cost Kolkata”SometimesYes, with a clear price page

The clinic lost traffic on the first row. The people who book appointments mostly come from rows three to five, and those are holding up.

What I’d do in your place

1. Find out which pages actually lost clicks

Open Google Search Console, go to Performance, and compare the last three months with the same three months a year earlier. Sort pages by the change in clicks. Then look at impressions for the same pages. If impressions are flat and clicks are down, an AI Overview or another Google feature is taking the click. If both are down, you have a ranking problem, which is a different fix.

2. Move effort from “how to” posts to money pages

For most small businesses I work with, the right move in 2026 is fewer general articles and better service pages. One page per service, one page per area you serve if you really serve it, a visible price or price range, real photos, and answers to the questions people ask before they call. These pages rank for searches Google doesn’t try to answer, because the searcher wants a business, not a paragraph.

3. Get your Google Business Profile right

“Near me” and “in [area]” searches show the map pack, not an AI essay. That box is decided mostly by your Business Profile: correct category, hours, photos, services, steady new reviews and replies to them. For a local business this is often worth more than any blog post. We wrote a full step-by-step guide to Google Business Profile earlier.

4. Keep informational content, but make it yours

Don’t delete the back-pain article. Change what it’s for. Add what an AI summary can’t: the clinic’s own photos of each exercise, a short video by the physiotherapist, a “when to stop and see someone” section based on real cases, and a clear link to book. Pages with first-hand experience are the ones Google’s AI tends to cite, and a citation still brings some clicks and a lot of brand recognition.

5. Measure enquiries, not visits

If you were judging SEO by traffic, 2026 will look bad. Judge it by calls, WhatsApp clicks, form fills and bookings instead. In our example, the clinic’s total Google visits fell by around 30% over the year, but bookings from Google stayed about the same, because the visits it lost were readers, not patients. Without proper tracking you’d never know that, and you might cut the budget that is still working. If your tracking isn’t set up, start with our post on GA4 set-up mistakes that hide your real leads.

What not to do

  • Don’t publish 50 AI-written articles to “win back” traffic. Google’s March 2026 core update hit exactly that kind of thin, recycled content hardest.
  • Don’t panic about every lost click. Ask whether the lost visitors were ever going to buy.
  • Don’t stop SEO altogether. People still search for businesses, and the ones that appear for “service + place” searches get the calls.

A good test for any page on your site: if Google’s AI summary answered the question perfectly, would the reader still have a reason to visit you? For a service page with your prices, photos and a booking button, the answer is yes. For a generic tips article, it usually isn’t, and that’s the page to rework first.

Not sure which of your pages AI Overviews are hurting?

Send me your website and I will check which pages lost clicks in Search Console and which searches are still worth your money. Free, with a reply within one business day.

Content Protection by DMCA.com

Sources

  1. Pew Research Center pewresearch.org
  2. Ahrefs ahrefs.com
  3. Hindi in September 2025 blog.google
Shubhankar Chakraborty

Written by

Founder, RoseSpark · digital marketer

Shubhankar is a digital marketer from near Kolkata, India, and the founder of RoseSpark and RoseSpark CRM. For many years his work has been to bring in leads and turn them into sales for agencies and their clients: running the campaigns, filling the pipeline and helping teams close the business. He has been writing about SEO and digital marketing on rosespark.in since 2019.